TREND TRUTH
“Loyal” Customers Still Wary of Store-Issued Credit
77% of shoppers report holding some kind of customer loyalty card, but only 40% report using store-issued credit cards. FGI Research asks: why the discrepancy?
We have all had the experience of checking out at the grocery store, pharmacy, or bookstore, and having the cashier ask whether we are part of the store’s customer rewards program. If we answer “no,” the next question is, inevitably, whether we want to join. New data from an FGI Research study indicate that over three-quarters of consumers say “yes” to this second question: that’s how many respondents report that they hold some kind of customer loyalty card, whether or not they also use a store-issued credit card.
And it’s no wonder that so many do. More and more companies offer rewards for customer loyalty. Not only retail outlets but hotels, restaurants and airlines use rewards as a way of promoting business and retaining customers. There are even online applications, like SCVNGR, which encourage consumers to build their own rewards programs. The FGI Research study, based on sample from FGI SmartPanelTM, assesses what it is about customer rewards that attracts consumers. The results illuminate why so many sign up for loyalty cards, notwithstanding concerns about privacy; and why they are nevertheless more reluctant to opt for alternatives, like store-issued (or “private-label”) credit cards.
Shoppers Want to Save
Knowing that 77% of shoppers hold some kind of loyalty card, FGI Research asked why they opted to sign up –and whether they were satisfied with the rewards that they received. Most shoppers (82%) say that rebates, discounts, and overall savings are the foremost advantages of having a loyalty card. The next advantage that users cite is being able to build up bonus points toward some kind of reward or discount, which 41% say is a perk. Meanwhile, 39% of those surveyed say they like being able to get personalized coupons, and 38% enjoy having access to special, members-only sales.
A full third of cardholders say they find no problems whatsoever with their membership, indicating a high level of satisfaction with rewards programs. Among those who have complaints, 64% wish only that they could get more rewards with their cards; the idea of a loyalty card, in itself, still attracts them.
Some aspects of rewards programs don’t register at all with users. Only 7% of respondents indicate that special treatment for members, like waiving the need for a receipt with returns, drew them to get a membership. Donation programs, which, for instance, automatically contribute a fraction of each sale to a charity of the user’s choice, excite a mere 8% of respondents. We can draw a variety of inferences from this body of data, the most important of which is that customers use loyalty cards most often for the savings, sales, and rewards from which they personally benefit. The biggest problem that customers have with loyalty cards is when they feel that these “rewards” are not forthcoming.
“What are the advantages of your customer loyalty card?”
Privacy Concerns a Roadblock
What about shoppers who opt out of customer rewards? Why do 14% of respondents report forgoing the opportunity to save money and enjoy other benefits? Some say they don’t shop frequently enough at any store to make the card worth having (43%), and others opt out because the programs don’t yield enough rewards to justify signing up (33%).
By far, the most-cited concern is privacy: 9 in 10 non-adopters report reluctance to sign up for the cards due to concerns about information security. Whether they don’t want stores giving out their data to third-parties (39%), don’t like that stores can keep track of their buying habits to create customer profiles (27%), or simply don’t like to issue too much personal information (24%), shoppers who opt out do so in order to protect their privacy. However, if they had a guarantee of privacy, two-thirds of respondents would be open to the idea of using loyalty cards.
Credit Card? No Thanks.
While an increasing number of retail outlets are starting to offer store-issued, or private-label, credit cards (like the Target RedCard), consumers avoid them for the most part. Only 40% of those surveyed in the TrendTruth study identify themselves as holders of such cards. As with loyalty cards, security issues deter many customers from using store-issued credit cards. But even were privacy less of an issue, consumers would remain wary: just half of those surveyed said they might be open to using a store-issued credit card under more secure circumstances. That’s because privacy is not the only issue discouraging shoppers from adopting.
ABC News: Risks of Private-Label Credit Cards
Over two-fifths of shoppers say they stay away from store-issued credit cards because the interest rate is too high. Others say the same about the annual fee (32%) and the financing percentage (31%). In short, many shoppers think the cost of maintaining a private-label credit card outweighs the benefits of having one. Loyalty cards may be more attractive simply because it’s free to sign up –and there are none of the dangers to users’ credit scores that store credit cards pose. In any case, a third of those surveyed say they don’t shop frequently enough at any store offering the service to justify opening a card.
Nevertheless, some shoppers have found the cards useful (as evinced by the forty percent who identify themselves as card-holders). Over half (56%) of these shoppers say they like the cards because of the discounts, savings and rebates that they offer. 46% appreciate having access to special members-only sales and events (46%), and 39% like that the cards have no annual or extra fees (39%). These users clearly think the benefits of having a card outweigh the risks and downsides.
Which Cards, Which Stores?
Private-label credit cards are most popular at department stores. Among those who carry store-issued cards, 62% report having gotten it from a department store. Meanwhile, only 24% got their card from a big-box retailer like Target. When it comes to non-credit loyalty cards, supermarkets (88%) and pharmacies (59%) rank first and second, while bookstores (31%) come in third.
“For which types of stores do you hold customer loyalty cards?”
How Many Cards?
FGI Research asked how many cards survey respondents held. Almost all (92%) have more than one. Nearly a quarter (22%) have two rewards cards. One fifth (20%) carry three. Slightly fewer (18%) carry four. A handful (17%) report holding over 7 customer loyalty cards. Meanwhile, most (60%) of those who have opened private-label credit cards say they only have one or two such cards.
We identified some possible explanations for the handful of shoppers who hold 7+ rewards cards. It may be that those who enroll in customer loyalty programs fall into one of two groups: either they have cards for the few stores where they shop most often (i.e. their preferred grocer, pharmacy, and bookstore), or they simply have the habit of saying “yes” every time they are asked to join a loyalty program. Those who hold cards to correspond to stores where they shop regularly would not likely carry more than 2-3. Those who say yes to every offer of a rewards card would likely have more than 7. Deeper research could help correlate consumers’ behavior (how many cards they hold) with their motivations (why they sign up for cards in the first place).
Actionable Insights
The results of this study indicate that the vast majority of shoppers use some kind of rewards card, whether that be a free customer loyalty card or a store-issued credit card. Many of those who don’t carry the cards would be more willing to do so if certain conditions, like those surrounding privacy, changed. Most shoppers remain wary of store-issued credit, largely due to high interest rates and other fees, but also due to dangers that such cards pose to their credit scores. For either type of card, some shoppers don’t adopt simply because they don’t shop frequently enough at any particular store to make signing up worthwhile. Targeted research and analysis could help businesses understand these non-adopters and secure their loyalty.
- Retailers interested in expanding their base of registered cardholders, whether for loyalty or store credit cards, should use an awareness and usage study fielded from their target demographic to understand whether and why their customers are using the cards –and, if they aren’t, why not.
- A survey of customers’ sentiments about each type of card could help retailers, and other businesses, seeking to start up a rewards program pinpoint the type of program that would best serve their objectives.
- Ongoing customer satisfaction tracking is indispensable to ensure that customers feel their rewards cards offer enough rewards and promise enough perceived benefits to warrant the effort it takes to sign up.
Next Steps You Can Take
- Learn more about the results of this study: complimentary access to the data in this report, including cross-tabulated results, is available upon request from FGI Research.
- Contact FGI Research: click here or call us at (919) 929-7759
- Explore FGI Research’s market research solutions, including custom panels, full service research, and our online sample (SmartPanel).
- Join FGI Research’s online panel to participate in future studies.
Survey Methods
Respondents: 400
Date of Survey: July 19-22, 2010
Sample Source: FGI SmartPanel
This nationally-representative sample consists of adults aged 18 and up and is balanced to the US population using recent census data. One can say with 95% confidence that the maximum margin of sampling error is ±4 percentage points.